How to price a wholesale deal: work backward from the end buyer’s numbers, not forward from what you want to earn. Start with a defensible ARV from renovated comps, subtract itemized repairs with a contingency, subtract the buyer’s holding, financing, and selling costs, and subtract the profit the buyer needs. What is left is the buyer’s maximum price. Your contract price plus your fee has to fit under it.
Wholesalers who price this way sell contracts quickly and earn repeat buyers. Wholesalers who price from their fee outward end up with stuck contracts. This guide shows the math, adjusts it for rentals and Florida-specific costs, and covers how to test the price before you sign.
Get Your Contract in Front of Matched Buyers
Register as a wholesaler on Off-Market.io, post your deal, and it is emailed to buyers and agents whose Buy Box fits.
The formula for how to price a wholesale deal
A simple version for flips:
Buyer’s maximum price = ARV − repairs − contingency − holding costs − financing costs − selling costs − buyer profit
Your maximum contract price = buyer’s maximum price − your fee
Many investors use a rule of thumb that caps their price at a percentage of ARV minus repairs. It is a quick screen, not a substitute for itemized numbers, and buyers in each Florida market use different percentages depending on prices and competition.
A worked example
| Line item | Example amount |
|---|---|
| ARV from renovated comps | 300,000 |
| Repairs (itemized) | 45,000 |
| Contingency | 5,000 |
| Holding costs (taxes, insurance, utilities) | 9,000 |
| Financing costs | 12,000 |
| Selling costs | 21,000 |
| Buyer profit target | 40,000 |
| Buyer’s maximum price | 168,000 |
| Your fee | 12,000 |
| Your maximum contract price | 156,000 |
These numbers are illustrations only. Use real comps, a contractor’s estimate, and your buyers’ actual cost assumptions in your market.
Getting the ARV right
- Use renovated sales, not average sales.
- Stay close: same neighborhood, similar size, age, and construction.
- Use recent sales.
- Adjust for pools, garages, lot size, and waterfront.
- Remove your best comp and see if the deal still works.
In Florida, also check whether comps are in a different flood zone or have newer roofs. Both affect what buyers will pay.
Estimating repairs buyers will trust
Walk the property with a contractor or inspector and itemize: roof, HVAC, electrical, plumbing, windows, kitchen, baths, flooring, paint, and exterior. Add a contingency for surprises. Buyers discount vague repair estimates more than high ones.
Setting the price on rental and BRRRR deals
Landlords price on income. Give them market rent, taxes, insurance considerations, HOA fees, and repairs to rent-ready. They will calculate their own cash flow and debt coverage. BRRRR buyers also want renovated sold comps to estimate the refinance value. Price the deal so it works on their numbers, not only on ARV.
Florida-specific costs that change the price
- Insurance, which can vary widely based on roof age, wind mitigation, and flood zone.
- Flood insurance requirements for financed buyers in certain zones.
- HOA or condo association fees, rules, and approvals.
- Permits for roofs, windows, and structural work.
- Longer holding times in slower or seasonal markets.
Ask a local insurance agent and lender how these affect a typical buyer before you set your price.
Test the price before you sign
- Run the numbers from the buyer’s side.
- Ask two or three trusted buyers what they would pay for a similar property.
- Check that your fee leaves the buyer a healthy margin.
- Build in time for inspections and showings.
- Sign only when at least one buyer type clearly wins.
Move More Wholesale Deals
Matched cash buyers and agents can message you directly on Off-Market.io.
Put a well-priced deal in front of matched buyers
Off-Market.io is an off-market real estate platform for buyers, sellers, agents, and wholesalers. For wholesalers, it is a disposition channel that fits alongside everything else in this guide on how to price a wholesale deal.
- Post a deal. You register as a wholesaler, then post a deal with the property details and asking price.
- Buy Box matching. Off-Market.io matches your deal to buyers and agents by location, price, property type, beds, baths, and size.
- Matched deals emailed. Matched deals are emailed to registered cash buyers and agents whose Buy Box fits the property.
- Private by default. Listings and search requests are accessible only to registered users.
- Direct conversations. Matched buyers and agents can message you through the platform.
- Help buyers close. Off-Market.io offers financing options through partners, including DSCR loans, bridge financing, hard money, construction loans, working capital, HELOC, and foreign national loans. Terms vary by lender.
- Closing support. The platform also offers connections to inspectors, contractors, title, lending, and insurance providers.
Common mistakes when setting the price
- Starting from your fee instead of the buyer’s maximum price.
- Using one high comp for ARV.
- Leaving out holding and selling costs.
- Ignoring Florida insurance and flood costs.
- Treating a rental like a flip.
How buyers check your numbers
Experienced buyers will rebuild your numbers in minutes. They pull their own comps, apply their own repair costs per square foot, and add their own holding time. If your ARV is high or your repairs are low, they will see it immediately and may not trust your next deal. Assume every number will be checked, and give buyers what they need to check it quickly: the comp addresses, the repair line items, and the assumptions you used.
Setting the price for different exit strategies
| Exit strategy | What drives the price | Key inputs to share |
|---|---|---|
| Fix and flip | ARV, repairs, holding time | Renovated comps, itemized repairs |
| Buy and hold | Rent and expenses | Rent comps, taxes, insurance notes, HOA |
| BRRRR | Rent and refinance value | Rent comps and renovated comps |
| Teardown or lot | Value of new construction | Lot size, zoning notes, new-build comps |
When a deal works for more than one exit, price it for the strongest one and say so in your package.
Negotiating with the seller after you know the numbers
Once you know the buyer’s maximum price, you know your ceiling with the seller. Be honest with sellers about condition and what investors will pay. A seller who understands the repair list and the comps is more likely to accept a realistic price and less likely to back out later.
Quick checklist before you send the deal
- ARV based on renovated comps you can name.
- Itemized repairs with a contingency.
- Holding, financing, and selling costs included.
- Buyer profit that matches what your buyers actually require.
- Florida insurance, flood, and HOA costs considered.
- Your fee fits under the buyer’s maximum price.
- At least one buyer type clearly wins at this price.
If any line is missing, fix it before you post. A complete, honest deal sells faster than a cheaper one with gaps.
Why honest numbers pay off
Wholesalers who send honest, well-supported numbers earn something more valuable than one fee: repeat buyers who act quickly on their next deal without re-checking everything. Over a year, a reputation for accurate ARVs and realistic repair estimates can matter more than squeezing extra margin out of any single contract.
The bottom line
Knowing how to price a wholesale deal comes down to thinking like your buyer. Use honest comps, itemized repairs, and the buyer’s real costs and profit, then fit your fee underneath. Deals priced that way sell quickly, and the buyers come back for the next one.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you price a wholesale deal?
Work backward from ARV: subtract repairs, contingency, holding, financing, and selling costs, and the buyer’s profit to find the buyer’s maximum price. Your contract price plus your fee must fit under it.
What is a maximum allowable offer?
It is the most a buyer can pay and still hit their profit target after all costs. Wholesalers use the buyer’s maximum price to set their own contract price.
Is the percentage-of-ARV rule reliable?
It is a quick screening tool. Itemized repairs and real costs give a much more reliable number, and the percentage buyers use varies by market.
How do I price a rental wholesale deal?
Give landlords rent, taxes, insurance considerations, HOA fees, and repairs to rent-ready, and price so the deal works on their income numbers.
What Florida costs affect wholesale prices?
Insurance, flood zone requirements, HOA or condo fees and approvals, permits, and holding time all affect what Florida buyers will pay.
How do I check my price before signing?
Run the buyer’s numbers, ask a few trusted buyers for their view on a similar property, and make sure your fee leaves them a healthy margin.
Can my buyers finance the deal?
On Off-Market.io, financing options are available through partners, including DSCR, bridge, hard money, construction loans, working capital, HELOC, and foreign national loans. Terms vary by lender.
How does Off-Market.io help sell a priced deal?
Post it on Off-Market.io and it is matched by location, price, property type, beds, baths, and size and emailed to registered buyers and agents whose Buy Box fits.
Ready to Dispo Your Next Florida Deal?
Join Off-Market.io and put your contracts in front of buyers who already said what they want.
